Why AI Implementation Stalls In Freight — And How To Get Back On Track

In this guide, we unpack the common gaps that block AI’s impact, and the practical plays to get implementation right on day one.

August 29, 2025

Looking to automate your email quoting?

Schedule a 30-minute product demo with expert Q&A.

Get started

From efficient rep workflows to smarter pricing, AI is single-handedly reshaping freight. It’s the edge that can help you outrun the market — if you know how to move from theory to performance.

Too often, AI rollouts stall between strategy and day‑to‑day operations. Adoption lags, reps waste hours on manual fixes, and leadership shelves the tools. Teams slip back into old processes, and the hunt for a solution that drives profitable growth continues.

It’s a frustrating cycle, but it isn’t inevitable. With the right approach, you can avoid these hurdles.

In this guide, we unpack the common gaps that block AI’s impact, and the practical plays to get implementation right on day one.

The Blind Spots That Turn AI Initiatives Into Costly Experiments

For freight brokerages, AI tech can unlock incredible gains, like faster quotes, automated load builds, and stronger win/loss reporting. But what looks good on paper can sometimes fall short on the floor.

With the wrong approach, barriers stack up quickly. Integration disrupts operations, stalling rollouts and leaving massive potential unrealized. Inconsistent output forces reps into manual rework. Add in team resistance — like concerns about relationship dynamics and fears of replacement — and adoption grinds to a halt.

But if you strip away the noise, AI implementation hurdles usually boil down to a few common issues.

Fragmented Information

The ML models behind AI are only as good as the data they’re trained on. If critical input is missing, your tool’s output will be incomplete.

In freight, teams weigh dozens of variables to make the right call. Quotes depend on the lane, distance, and mode of transportation. Scheduling hinges on facility hours, fleet capacity, and customer preferences. And if any special equipment or service conditions are required, decisions become even more complex.

When reps juggle customer service, data entry, and pricing, information often ends up siloed in local spreadsheets, inboxes, and carrier portals — if it’s documented at all. Take dock door info or pickup numbers, for example. If these details are shared over the phone, reps often rush to notify dispatch, then jump to the next urgent request without recording them.

Without this deeper context, AI tools can’t factor in details about carrier availability, customer preferences, and partnership dynamics. The results are costly: inconsistent quotes, missed service requirements, and subpar customer service.

Limited Data Density

Even if teams document every detail, AI tools can only learn from clear, repeatable patterns. But in freight, data sometimes lacks the density to shape consistent trends.

Every brokerage operates differently based on their customer mix, SLAs, and pricing strategy. Even within the same company, reps make different calls based on context. Say a carrier that avoids certain routes might make an exception due to road closures. This unique event may create conflicting signals that throw off the AI’s algorithm.

Because of this variance, your AI solution might struggle with rare or context-dependent situations. Common lanes with simple instructions are easy to quote. But handling infrequent requests, such as custom routes or specialized freight needs, can be challenging.

Automation Without Human Judgment

AI might recognize common patterns — but without human judgment in the loop, it won’t deliver meaningful results.

Many brokerages deploy AI to scale workflows at a low cost. They use automation to increase carrier outreach and email volume, hoping to capture more revenue. But without human intelligence guiding which opportunities are a good fit and when to engage, this approach often backfires. Constant contact and irrelevant touches overwhelm carriers — and outreach effectiveness fades.

Instead of driving growth, “spray and pray” automation often weakens conversion rates as fatigued carriers become unresponsive. What started as an efficiency play becomes a disadvantage, with reps working twice as hard to rebuild customer relationships.

AI Implementation Strategies That Maximize ROI

AI gaps don’t have to stall progress. Whether you’ve hit pause on your rollout or you’re still planning a launch, a few simple tactics will cut implementation friction and unlock the operational value you’re chasing.

Turn Disconnected Data Into Actionable AI Context

Your AI tool needs detailed system information to automate tasks precisely. Before you use it on the floor, give it a reliable data foundation to learn from.

Start by integrating data with your TMS to capture siloed knowledge. Upload local spreadsheets and connect sources like load boards, carrier portals, and WMSs. Then, sit down with the team and document any missing decision inputs, like repeat add-on fees or carrier rankings based on past performance. Create custom TMS fields so these details are collected the same way, every time.

Strengthen context further by coaching reps to ask for quote feedback. Real-time win/loss data doesn’t just enhance your AI output — it also helps you spot market shifts and refine your pricing strategy.

Set clear rules about when, why, and how you follow up so customers aren’t overwhelmed and reps get valuable pricing intel with minimal effort. Direct Traffic Solutions built a culture of data collection with Vooma, pulling real-time carrier insights straight from their calls to power smarter decisions.

Teach Your AI Tool How You Work

AI isn’t a standalone tool — it’s a teammate. To add value, AI needs to understand the logic behind your reps’ judgment and how it shapes operational outcomes.

Run guided sessions to unpack how your team makes decisions. Use your TMS to find common workflow scenarios and red flags. For instance, reps might weigh recent performance over reputation, so a well-known carrier could get a higher quote if they’ve had delays lately. Work with IT to encode as many patterns as possible into your AI system.

And don’t pull the plug at the first sign of errors. As your tool adapts, occasional missteps can still occur. Instead, schedule weekly retros to review AI output. Look for quote variance by customer and lane, and check why inbound calls are disqualified. Refine internal processes to keep patterns consistent, then let your AI evolve.

With this strategy, you’ll create a smarter ML model and build more intelligent processes over time. Take Zengistics. They plugged Vooma into their workflows so the platform knows exactly how they work. The payoff? The team automated 98% of their order entry and freed up 600+ weekly hours for high-value tasks, including supply chain modeling and analytics.

Automate High-Volume Tasks With Little Nuance

AI can improve your team’s efficiency and amplify their capabilities — as long as you point it to the right work.

To do this, survey your team about the daily processes they want to improve. Work with them to spot repetitive tasks, copy‑paste workflows, and any activities that burn time without tangible results. Keep any activities that require real‑time trade-offs or relationship‑sensitive communication in their court.

This approach unlocks fast productivity wins and keeps reps focused on high‑leverage work, like handling complex orders and enhancing customer experiences to drive long-term revenue.

And the impact compounds. C.H. Robinson shows what happens when AI is used strategically — quotes go out quicker, and your win rate increases. Similarly, tools like Vooma focus automation where it delivers the most value, like screening inbound carrier calls and qualifying them against leading verification tools. AI does the heavy lifting while reps zero in on expert-level tasks, like high‑priority calls and approvals.

Transform Your AI Initiatives Into Scalable, Revenue-Driving Operations

While these strategies will help launch an AI transformation that drives real results, the right AI partner will multiply this lift.

Vooma combines intelligent automation and industry expertise to help you move more freight, power scale, and access actionable insights across your operations. Here’s how:

  • Strategic, high-touch partnership: Vooma’s experts guide you through implementation, closing any gaps before they affect your operations. Once you’re up and running, they work with you to continuously improve and fine-tune the platform to your needs.
  • Optimized freight workflows: Vooma streamlines time-consuming rep work so you can focus on your customers. Along the way, the platform captures real-time, high-value data, giving you the intel to sharpen your pricing strategy and competitive edge.
  • More revenue opportunities: Vooma’s AI agents handle every order with human-level precision, boosting speed-to-quote and cutting error rates. As a result, your team scales throughput to capture more freight — without the extra headcount.

Ready to turn AI into ROI? Book a demo today.

See Vooma in Action

Schedule a demo in 36 seconds.

Book a demo